Behind the third window of That Boutique-y Whisky Company’s 2019 Advent Calendar we will be reviewing each day until the 24th of December was hidden a 2 year-old rye spirit from the New York: the New York Distilling Company 2yo Batch 3. Bottled at 47.7% abv, this rye spirit bottled by that Boutique-y Rye Company is not whisky yet (in Europe and UK, but in the USA it is), but it’s available from Master of Malt for ÂŁ37.95. But if it’s not whisky yet, should we review it?
Yes we should!

Color:
Deep old gold like an old Madeira with an orange hue. A swirl reveal fat heads that wait a bit before becoming slow thick legs.

Nose:
Coldorak: Initial nose on spices (ginger, cinnamon) and vanilla. Very sweet and spirity, oranges, caramel, a bit of rye bread and some herbal notes.
AinulindalĂ«: Quite immediately very spicy – cinnamon and ginger and also some notes of juniper in the background, over caramel. There’s a slight fruity note I can’t quite place. I’d say kiwi.
Palate:
Coldorak: Spicy with ginger, cinnamon, chilli-pepper, then when the spices tone down a bit, the mid palate reveals oak, caramel and hints of grapefruit. The mouthfeel is a bit watery even with a 47.7% abv, it misses complexity and texture.
AinulindalĂ«: The mouth first brings out a dunnage kind of taste – mustiness, dampness, to then go on caramel strongly, all the while showing these notes of juniper/spices again.
Finish:
Coldorak: Short and warm on oak, cinnamon and caramel, a bit disappointing to be honest.
Ainulindalë: Very low key to me even though some fruit stays behind despite all the caramel.
Rating:
Coldorak: 80/100
Ainulindalë: 82/100

