Scotland Archives - More Drams, Less Drama

Four Macallan 12 yo and a 20 yo Speymalt

12th August 202611th August 2026Coldorak

Macallan has so far been something of a blind spot on More Drams Less Drama. We have only reviewed a pair of secret Macallans – both bottled by Le Gus’t – and they were, frankly, stunning. This time, however, there is no need for concealment: we are heading directly into one of Speyside’s most recognisable names, through four versions of the Macallan 12-Year-Old Sherry Oak Cask and a mature 2000 Speymalt from Gordon & MacPhail.

The four 12-year-olds should make for a particularly useful exercise in comparison. A whisky with such a fixed identity on paper can still evolve through changing cask sourcing, batch composition, bottling eras and the inevitable small adjustments of a long-lived official range. Adding Gordon & MacPhail’s 20-year-old Speymalt 2000 offers a different perspective altogether: a longer-aged, independently bottled Macallan, selected and presented beyond the official Sherry Oak framework. Together, they should tell us something about consistency, evolution, and the many ways Macallan’s sherried spirit can be interpreted.

Two Bowmore 2005 The Whisky Agency

10th August 202610th August 2026Coldorak

Back in February we were stunned by a few magnificent official Bowmore, so this time I’m turning to two independent bottlings. Rather fittingly, they are sister casks released by the same bottler and retailer, The Whisky Agency: both were distilled in 2005, matured in the same type of cask and bottled in 2026. The question, then, is whether these two Bowmore prove closely aligned in character or reveal meaningful differences between casks.

4 Springbank 15-year-old and Batch Variation

7th August 20265th August 2026Coldorak

After our Irish detour, we are back in Scotland, and more specifically in one of the country’s most obsessively followed distilleries: Springbank. This tasting brings together four 15-year-olds – an older bottle from 2006 and the 2024, 2025 and 2026 releases – for a simple but revealing exercise in batch variation, with the aim of seeing how much the same age statement can shift over time while still remaining recognisably Springbank.

That kind of comparison is exactly where Springbank tends to reward attention. Even when the age statement stays fixed, the cask mix, batch composition and bottling conditions can subtly reshape the whisky from one release to the next, so lining up an older bottling against three recent ones should tell us a lot about continuity and drift, and perhaps even about what we really mean when we say a whisky is ‘the same’ from year to year. When the Local Barley has age, cask and farm variation, the Springbank 15-year-old shows stability.

Three Auchroisk: 1975 / Flora and Fauna / Chorlton

Auchroisk 1975 / Flora & Fauna / Chorlton

31st July 202631st July 2026Coldorak

Auchroisk is one of those Speyside distilleries that most whisky drinkers know indirectly, because much of its spirit has long gone into blends rather than into a broad official single-malt range. That makes a trio like this especially attractive: a rare 1975 bottling from the old “The Singleton” era, the 10-year-old Flora & Fauna, and a 14-year-old independent bottling from Chorlton Whisky all show different faces of the same distillery across different periods and bottling philosophies.

3 Old Fettercairn: 80s, 90s & 2008

29th July 202629th July 2026Coldorak

Fettercairn is one of those Highland distilleries that has quietly built a very distinctive identity without ever becoming noisy about it. This tasting brings together three bottles from very different moments in Fettercairn’s history: a NAS single malt bottled in the 1980s, a 10-year-old bottled in the 1990s, and a 2008 independent bottling from Douglas Laing. On paper, they span three eras of Fettercairn presentation; in the glass, they should offer a useful look at how the distillery’s spirit has been handled, interpreted, and sold across time, even though it lacks expressions from their current core range. More than just a vertical in age or bottling date, this is a small archive of how Fettercairn has been seen by both official and independent bottlers, and of how a once fairly discreet Highland malt can reveal surprising depth when you line up the older releases.

5 Blair Athol From the 1970s to 2020s

27th July 202627th July 2026Coldorak

Blair Athol is one of those distilleries that rewards a broad tasting approach because its character has shifted noticeably across eras and bottling styles. Here, five whiskies – two 8-year-olds bottled in the 1970s and late 1980s, the 12-year-old Flora & Fauna, a 2010 independent release from Elixir Distillers’ Single Malts of Scotland range, and a 35-year-old from Signatory Vintage – offer a compact but revealing look at how this Highland malt can move from older official bottlings to a more contemporary cask-selected expression.

What makes this line-up especially interesting is the mix of perspectives it gives on the same distillery. The two older 8-year-olds should show Blair Athol in a more old-school official guise. The Flora & Fauna provides the classic distillery bottling reference point, and the 2010 Elixir Distillers and 1988 Signatory releases bring in the independent bottlers’ interpretation of Blair Athol’s spirit. Taken together, they create a useful comparison of age, era, and bottling philosophy, and a reminder that Blair Athol has long been more than just a quiet component of blends, as we’ve been able to see on these pages already.

Annandale 2016 Man O'Words and Holyrood Pitch

Recent Lowlands: Annandale 2016 & Holyrood Pitch

24th July 202623rd July 2026Coldorak

We’re taking a first look today at two newer Lowland distilleries in Scotland: Annandale and Holyrood. Both are still relatively small compared with the industry’s long-established heavyweights, but each has already built up a fair amount of output through official releases and, in some cases, independent bottlings. Today, though, I’m staying on the official side with an Annandale 2016 Man O’Words and Holyrood Pitch.

Kilchoman Loch Gorm & Sanaig Cask Strength

Kilchoman Loch Gorm 2021 & 2026 vs Sanaig CS

22nd July 202622nd July 2026Coldorak

It’s been a few years since my last – and only – Kilchoman review, so it feels overdue to bring the distillery back to the tasting table. This time I’m looking at three sherry-influenced expressions: Loch Gorm 2021, Loch Gorm 2026, and Sanaig Cask Strength. Previously I found Kilchoman a little hard to love, particularly its pronounced farmyard note, which I also struggled with in Ledaig, but my palate has shifted over time and that character bothers me far less now. With that in mind, I’m curious to see how Kilchoman shows today, and as always, my impressions should be read with a pinch of salt, as they inevitably reflect my own preferences and subjective leanings.

Dalwhinnie 15-Year-Old vs 2008 NSS

20th July 202620th July 2026Coldorak

Dalwhinnie 15-year-old has been a staple of whisky bars and whisky occasional drinkers’ cabinets for years, but is it worth it? Like most of Diageo distilleries’ core range expressions, it’s targeted at large retailers and occasional whisky drinkers, so not really my usual readers. But this doesn’t mean it should be dismissed and ignored by this humble blog, so let’s take a look at it and compare it to a (really) rare independent bottling of Dalwhinnie, with a 2008 from North Star Spirits.

Five Glen Moray To Reach My 100th

15th July 202624th July 2026Coldorak

Reaching 100 Glen Moray tasted feels less like crossing a finish line and more like coming home after a very long, very enjoyable detour. This new line‑up of five independent bottlings – from The Whisky Cask, High Spirits, Archives/Whiskybase, Asta Morris and Celtic Whisky Distillerie – is both another step on that journey and a small personal milestone. These aren’t ‘official story’ bottlings, but rather five external, sometimes quirky lenses through which to look at Glen Moray’s spirit: different casks, different philosophies, different markets, all converging on the same Elgin DNA. Taken together, they say a lot about how adaptable Glen Moray is, and why it lends itself so well to being interpreted by bottlers beyond the distillery gates.