Seven Ben Nevis 1996

After Monday’s and Wednesday’s reviews, we are staying with Ben Nevis for one final deep dive – and this time the focus narrows to a single, particularly compelling vintage: 1996. Seven whiskies are on the table, including one official bottling and six independent interpretations from Celtic Whisky Distillerie for Le Comptoir Irlandais, Hunter Laing, Caora, Thompson Bros., The Whisky Jury and Milroy’s.

A shared distillation year does not mean seven identical whiskies. Quite the opposite: this is a chance to see how different casks, bottling dates and independent selection philosophies have shaped the same Ben Nevis spirit over time. With official and independent bottlings side by side, the line-up should offer a useful snapshot of why 1996 Ben Nevis has become such a sought-after vintage – and just how many different directions this muscular, idiosyncratic Highland malt can take when left in the hands of different bottlers. We’ll go from the lowest to the highest ABV.

Ben Nevis 1996 Les Fûts Oubliés Celtic Whisky Distillerie (2023) Review

We start with a Ben Nevis 1996 26-year-old ‘Les Fûts Oubliés’ single cask. It was distilled in 1996 and, unusually, matured not in the Highlands but in France, in the Brittany region (specifically the Côtes-d’Armor coastal region near Pleubian), where casks from Scottish distilleries were shipped decades ago and left ‘forgotten’ until Celtic Whisky Distillerie rediscovered them for this ‘Les Fûts Oubliés’ (The Forgotten Casks) series for Le Comptoir Irlandais. It was bottled in 2023 (but released only in June 2026) at 26 years of age from hogshead cask #1850, at 46.5% ABV, with no chill filtration and no added colouring. The outturn was limited to 209 bottles, released as part of ‘Série 2 : Le Réveil,’ featuring artwork by street artist Averi. This was released at a very reasonable €195 but is sold out online. You’ll have to check your local Comptoir Irlandais shop if they still have some.

Ben Nevis 1996 Les Fûts Oubliés Celtic Whisky Distillerie (2023)

Colour:

Deep gold.

Nose:

Neat: The nose shows a nice intensity. Fudge and orchard fruit (apples, peaches) open things up, with tart tropical fruits (pineapples, mangoes and hints of passion fruit) just behind. Nougat and dried herbs follow, giving way to a slightly vegetal edge. Underneath sits a generous honeyed sweetness and waxy richness. After some aeration, the nose becomes funky, with fruit peel compost, cured meat, rancio and some sweet and sour sauce.

Palate:

Neat: Sweet on entry – white and brown sugar, before oak spices and bitterness build steadily, bringing a tingling, warming heat that stays pleasant and on tension, rather than aggressive. A rising acidity appears, closer to sour Haribo than citrus, layered over an underlying waxy, honeyed texture, mustard seeds, tropical and finally citrus fruits (maracuja, grapefruit, lemon).

Finish:

The finish is long, with tart apple and orange marmalade leading into spent tea leaves, chilli and pepper. It dries out gradually, with a touch of bitterness creeping in at the end.

Comments:

Lovely tropical and funky Ben Nevis. As this was the first pour of a freshly opened bottle, it could gain oxidisation and a bit of time, but I hadn’t opened my bottle yet, and just did for this week’s series of Ben Nevis reviews. In any case, it shows potential and as it deserves a 7.5 right now, it could rise to an 8 or a bit more, as I revisit it over time. (Well, after letting some sitting in my glass for two more hours, it raises to an 8!)

Rating: 8/10


Ben Nevis 1996 Milroy’s of Soho (2021) Review

We continue with a Ben Nevis 1996 25 Year Old, bottled by Milroy’s of Soho in 2021, from cask #20, a refill sherry butt. Milroy’s of Soho, the legendary London bottle shop on Greek Street founded in 1964, is known for handpicking single casks, and this Ben Nevis was distilled on 09.02.1996 and bottled on 28.06.2021, giving it 25 years of maturation entirely in the refill sherry butt. It’s bottled at 47.6% ABV, presumably non-chill-filtered and natural colour in line with Milroy’s typical single-cask presentation, though this isn’t explicitly confirmed. No mention of bottle count either, and it’s sold out anyway.

Ben Nevis 1996 Milroy’s of Soho (2021)

Colour:

Burnished.

Nose:

Neat: The nose opens with sherry-driven notes of dates and nuttiness, with honey rounding things out. Dried apricot, plums, papaya, mango sit over a creamy texture, joined by prunes, salt, cured meat, and umami. Forest honey and a faint mineral edge tie it together, giving a dried-fruit-forward, savoury sherry nose.

Palate:

Neat: The palate is medium-bodied and sweet. Tropical fruit and orange lead the way, followed by milk chocolate, dried mangoes and apricots. Cured meat, salt, mustard and an oily texture bring a savoury, umami edge, joined by leather, with just a touch of woody bitterness.

Finish:

Long, sweet, with chocolate and tobacco, plus a slight peppery tingle on the tip of the tongue. Coffee and prunes develop alongside old motor oil and oily tobacco leaves, closing on a savoury, meaty, slightly industrial note that lingers well past the initial sweetness.

Comments:

Another really good and tropical Ben Nevis. Not a tropical fruit bomb, but still tropical enough to tick some of the boxes. Then, you add funk and umami, and that’s quite a good moment for you glass in hand.

Rating: 7.5/10


Ben Nevis 1996 Thompson Brothers (2024) Review

We continue with a Ben Nevis 1996 28 Year Old, bottled by Thompson Bros (Dornoch Distillery) in October 2024 from cask #1166, a refill sherry butt. Distilled on the second of August 1996, it was bottled at 47.8% ABV, cask strength, natural colour and non-chill-filtered, with an outturn of 594 bottles and artwork by Whisky Hobo, representing Matsumoto Taketsuru, founder of Nikka Whisky, current owner of Ben Nevis. It retailed for around €390 in Europe (I paid €375 for mine) and £345 in the UK, but is sold out.

Ben Nevis 1996 Thompson Brothers (2024)

Colour:

Chestnut.

Nose:

Neat: Kiwi, gooseberries, grapes, oranges, and plums lead, with chocolate digestive biscuit richness replacing heavy sherry. Tropical fruits – mango, dragonfruit, lychee, guava, papaya, apricots, and overripe pineapple – sit alongside waxy olives, chalk, dark caramel, wet pebbles, and umami. Dew, musty foliage, stone-fruit pits, and salty sand. A sweeter register adds lemon jelly, icing, vanilla, beeswax, acacia honey, a light note of solvent, mint, hazelnut, and marzipan.

Palate:

Neat: Papaya, kiwi, pineapple, orange, and gooseberries arrive drizzled with chocolate sauce, alongside bruised apple and toffee sauce. A malty base recalls Maltesers and salted chocolate, with wax, grapefruit, mango, and pomelo, plus a tiny pinch of pepper. The mouthfeel is medium-bodied and slightly oily. Then, tropical fruit syrup, menthol, and medicinal patches, popsicle sticks and sea shells move into woody, mineral notes. A sweeter take brings more tropical fruits, banana, peach, vanilla, acacia honey, and butter cookies, with background cloves and anise.

Finish:

Medium to long, with a slight bitter edge, sponge cake, red berries, and coffee grounds, closing on a soft whisper of eucalyptus. Pineapple, mango, lychee, apple juice, acacia honey, vanilla, mint, anise, cloves, and grapefruit, slightly drying out at the very end.

Comments:

We definitely cranked things a notch with this Thompson Brothers bottling. Despite the ABV being just very slightly higher than the previous two bottlings reviewed, everything is more intense, more tropical, and more everything. I don’t know what happened at Ben Nevis back in 1996, but they must have been blessed by the whisky gods and angels. Absolutely stunning. Looking back, it was really expensive, but now that I’ve opened my bottle, I really don’t regret it!

Rating: 8.5/10


Ben Nevis 1996 Old Malt Cask Hunter Laing (2019) Review

Next, we have a Ben Nevis 1996 23 Year Old, bottled by Hunter Laing as part of their Old Malt Cask series, from single cask #HL15973, a refill butt. It was distilled in October 1996 and bottled in October 2019. It’s presented at 50% ABV, the Old Malt Cask series’ standard preferred strength, natural colour and non-chill-filtered, with an outturn of 601 bottles. There’s a shop listing it close to €400 in Austria, but I doubt it was sold at that high a price back in 2019.

Ben Nevis 1996 Old Malt Cask Hunter Laing (2019)

Colour:

Deep gold.

Nose:

Neat: Melon and guava candies open things up vanilla, raspberry, cherry syrup and pineapple – plus salt and condensed milk. Orchard fruits, canned peach syrup, pineapple, and mango sit alongside vanilla, butter cookies, and cashew nuts. Finally, raisins, chocolate (Nutella), and plums.

With water: Reduction brings dusty books, orchard trees in autumn, musty cellars and a lovely melancholy, if that makes sense.

Palate:

Neat: Creamy and oily, carrying tropical and red fruits – mango, raspberry, strawberry, cherry – with dusty earth and wood. Multivitamin juice sweetness pairs with pineapple, mango, pomelo, lime, and ginger, plus freshly cut grass and honey. Almond cream and raisins bring soft, warm wood notes and lovely softness.

With water: A good pinch of pepper, more cut grass, oranges sprinkled with sugar, and something reminiscing of a mix of cold milk and orange juice I liked when I was a student.

Finish:

Long and mild, with refreshing fruits and dry summer grass, plus a bitter hint of grapefruit. Earth, grass, paper, and a distant hint of cigarette smoke linger in the background.

Comments:

Delicious Ben Nevis again, that benefits from the higher ABV to get more intensity and room to play a little bit with the pipette afterwards. And play with it you might like, as it gives it some kind of melancholy (for me) that really resonates. Reaaaally good.

Rating: 8/10


Ben Nevis 1996 Caora (2019) Review

I realised I had never reviewed this little gem from the Swiss bottler, and it was just in time to fit after the Hunter Laing in terms of ABV! This Ben Nevis 1996 Caora comes from a small independent Swiss bottler releasing under its own label, sourced from Refill Hogshead #1381. It was distilled in 1996 and bottled in 2019 at 23 years old, yielding 321 bottles (50 cl ones) at 50.7% ABV, with no additional finishing – just the single refill hogshead. This release was not really exported, and I had to get help from a friend working in Switzerland to get a bottle, for the equivalent of €94 at the time.

Ben Nevis 1996 Caora (2019)

Colour:

Pale gold.

Nose:

Neat: Lime, green apple with waxy skin, and citrus oils lead, with fresh wild herbs. Yellow and tropical fruits dominate too – overripe banana, orange, multivitamin juice, lychee, pineapple, mango, and peach – layered with vanilla and farmer’s butter. Some virgin olive oil appears alongside honeydew, minerals, limestone, and almonds.

With water: The nose shifts more lemony and slightly dusty, and the overripe bananas are toned down.

Palate:

Neat: Wax, citrus, pepper, and a fine mineral edge meet milk chocolate, with well-balanced acidity and fruity sweetness. Tropical fruit returns – mango, apricots, pineapple – alongside creamy, tingling peaches, wax, honeycomb, white chocolate, lime, and powdered sugar. Oily and punchy with syrupy sweetness, marzipan, and a few coconut shavings, backed by a soft bitterness from grapefruit and lime that balances the sweet pineapple and mango with a gentle pepper note.

With water: The palate turns more mineral and earthy, with the fruit becoming sourer. Maracuja, oak spices and some chalk.

Finish:

Bitter with pepper, citrus, and wax, plus a touch of chili and freshly ground coffee, with well-judged length. Vanilla sweetness stays barely dry before turning spicy, while mango, floral, and perfume notes linger alongside medium-long warmth, zest, grapefruit, and coconut milk.

Comments:

Another splendid 1996 Ben Nevis, with the cask taking a back seat and letting the spirit shine and show its well desired tropical side. It was complicated to buy a bottle and get it back to France, but that deserved the effort.

Rating: 8/10


Ben Nevis 1996 Private Cask (2016) Review

Ben Nevis 19 Year Old 1996/2016, ‘Private Cask’ #1424, is an official bottling (OB) direct from the distillery in Fort William, distilled in 1996 and bottled in 2016 for a private cask owner via Whisky.Auction. It’s presented at 51.8% ABV, single cask, 70 cl format. It launched at £115 on Whisky.Auction and rose steadily in secondary-market value, later selling for £340 at auction after Serge Valentin’s glowing Whiskyfun review drew wider attention. This release is obviously sold out.

Ben Nevis 1996 Private Cask (2016)

Colour:

Pale gold.

Nose:

Neat: Fragrant yellow fruit – peach, banana, melon – sits alongside milk, apple, cream, and vanilla, calmed by some bottle age developing old-wine character. A fruit-bomb impression also comes through, with jams, lemon and pineapple, with some oily richness. Then appear some mineral notes as well as crushed nettles and chalk, aspirin, with white flowers, light peat, a wool closet and lemon citron candies.

With water: Aniseed, verbena, and a more medicinal, herbal character dominate, turning extremely mineral and pure with the wood becoming almost silent. Fruit deepens and ripens toward pomelo, grapes and red apples.

Palate:

Neat: The palate has a nice and strong intensity, without being hot. The palate carries yellow fruits, peaches and minerals with a mellow hoppy sense; citrus, vanilla, and nutmeg fill the middle, with cinnamon and black pepper showing clear distillery character alongside an obvious minerality and a touch of toasty smoke. Good body and oily texture bring fruity bombs and a nice waxy feeling. Then, seawater, rapeseed oil, light tarry background notes, herbal ointments, and white wines from the Loire region.

With water: The palate turns immensely fat and richly waxy, resurging in force; with the citrus fruits being intensified, and some tropical fruits appearing. Superb.

Finish:

The finish is long, as fruits linger with citrus, vanilla, minerals, and a lightly astringent peat, with coffee beans, limestone, pink salt, gentian and wet pebbles.

Comments:

What a superb, intense, naked, pure and chiselled Ben Nevis! Despite this 1996 Ben Nevis not being especially tropical, it shows a beautiful and naked distillate, lightly peaty, elegantly fruity and mineral, and with a nice waxy mouthfeel. Absolutely stunning dram, one I will have to track down at auction and be prepared to pay an unreasonable price for. And the addition of a few drops of water even manages to enhance it.

Rating: 9/10


Ben Nevis 1996 The Whisky Jury (2021) Review

We end this high-flying Ben Nevis session with the Ben Nevis 1996 cask #1473, bottled by The Whisky Jury for their 2nd anniversary release. It was distilled in October 1996 and bottled in August 2021, after maturing in a single sherry butt matured for 24 years, bottled at 52.8% ABV, non-chill-filtered and naturally coloured, with an outturn of 354 bottles. As all Ben Nevis 1996 later bottled by The Whisky Jury, it very quickly sold out.

Ben Nevis 1996 The Whisky Jury (2021)

Colour:

Yellow gold.

Nose:

Neat: A clean, old school sherry character leads with tobacco, a cigar box, raisin rolls, and bready walnut notes, joined by red berries, blood oranges, stewed apples, and preserved cherries, plus dark honey and chalky minerality. Cloves, light Christmas cake, and honey appear too, alongside tropical fruit (pineapple, mangoes), orange, apple, milk chocolate, cinnamon, and a distinctive cola note.

With water: Fruit notes come out more prominently with a drop of water, becoming riper and more expressive.

Palate:

Neat: Sherry-driven walnuts, spice, chocolate, and herbal notes lead, with flashes of pink grapefruit and exotic fruits before going to minerals and eucalyptus. Sweet and sour warmth combines sherry oak with berries, jam, orange, and mangoes, while a cinnamon and ginger prickle runs through an oily, medium-thick mouthfeel alongside plums, raisins, old leather, and wood. Punchy and rich, tropical fruit and red fruit syrup, dark chocolate, and mentholated herbal notes.

With water: The palate does not change much, but the mouthfeel becomes creamier and silky.

Finish:

Long, closing on liquorice, passion fruit, pineapple, chocolate-coated walnuts, Amontillado, and tobacco leaf, with cinnamon spice fading into gentle warmth, dusty dunnage, and bitter dark chocolate.

Comments:

The Whisky Jury gained quite some reputation thanks to his good source of Ben Nevis 1996 casks, and I can see why, as it is indeed a superb Ben Nevis, showing all the flavours we expect for a sherry matured Ben Nevis from that famed vintage.

Rating: 8/10

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.