Reviews Archives - More Drams, Less Drama

Circumstance 2019 Glentauchers 2013 Thompson Brothers

Circumstance 2019 / Glentauchers 2013 Thompson Bros

28th March 202527th March 2025Coldorak

The Thompson Brothers are quite some busy men. On top of their strongly recognised whisky bar, their independent bottling operation (that interests us today and did in the past) and their Dornoch distillery, they’re now crowdfunding for their second and bigger distillery, Struie Distillery. And whilst I haven’t had the chance to try any Dornoch whisky yet, I had the chance to go have a few drams at the Dornoch Castle Whisky Bar a few years ago, and try a few of their independent bottlings. They’re very good at those activities, and judging from what I read, they’re good at doing whisky too. But for now, let’s stay on the Thompson’s independent bottling hat, with a review of two bottlings: a Circumstance 2019 and a Glentauchers 2013 Thompson Bros.

Glenrothes, Glentauchers & Caol Ila 100 Proof Signatory Vintage

Glentauchers, Glenrothes and Caol Ila 100 Proof Signatory Vintage

26th March 202525th March 2025Coldorak

In the UK, “100 proof” signifies a spirit with 57.15% alcohol by volume, often rounded to 57.1% ABV. It also names an extensive, affordable series by independent bottler Signatory Vintage, with over 30 releases filled at 57.1% ABV (some of them being ‘Exceptional Casks‘). We are examining three early releases in this series: the Glentauchers, Glenrothes, and Caol Ila 100 Proof Signatory Vintage, specifically numbers 6, 8, and 10.

Two Glen Garioch 2003 SMWS

24th March 202523rd March 2025Coldorak

The Scotch Malt has purchased numerous Glen Garioch 2003 casks, as we reviewed one a few years ago. Whiskybase records about fifty 2003 Glen Garioch bottlings by the SMWS, and their ratings indicate that the Scotch Malt Whisky Society made excellent selections. Let’s reduce this extensive list slightly by reviewing two Glen Garioch 2003 SMWS bottlings: the 19.71 (an 18-year-old) and the 19,103 from January 2025’s outturn, and the latest Glen Garioch 2003 release.

Glen Moray 1986 SMWS vs 1991 The Whisky Barrel

21st March 202528th March 2025Coldorak

Glen Moray is renowned for its affordable core range, which offers a variety of options for entry-level enthusiasts. Their extensive Elgin Classic collection is celebrated for its budget-friendly single malts, featuring a diverse array of finishes to suit all preferences. As you explore their Heritage range, you’ll find high-quality aged single malts that remain reasonably priced, unlike the steep increases often seen with competitors. However, for those seeking even older or more unique expressions, rare one-offs (like the Glen Moray Mastery) or independent bottlings are the way to go. Today, we’re comparing two single casks aged 30 years or more: a Glen Moray 1986 SMWS vs 1991 The Whisky Barrel.

Armorik Small Batch Chouchenn

19th March 202518th March 2025Coldorak

Two and a half years ago, I reviewed two Armorik single malts finished in Chouchen casks: one was an official single cask with a second, extended maturation in a Chouchen cask, and the other was independently bottled by That Boutique-y Whisky Company. Recently, Warenghem released the Armorik Small Batch Chouchenn, which features a double maturation and is bottled as a small batch rather than a single cask.

Nine Dingle Celtic Wheel of the Year

17th March 202517th March 2025Coldorak

For the first time, I’ve planned ahead for St. Patrick’s Day to prepare an Irish whiskey review. We’re taking this opportunity to do something I’ve been eagerly awaiting: reviewing the complete Dingle Celtic Wheel of the Year collection. I waited for the collection to be complete, then I waited a bit longer, partly due to procrastination, as reviewing nine whiskies isn’t something that can be rushed or done in a single day. I’m only human! Now that the collection is complete, let’s dive into all nine Dingle Celtic Wheel of the Year expressions!

No Age Declared Blended Malt Masam

14th March 202513th March 2025Coldorak

Silvano Samaroli was a pioneering figure in the world of whisky and spirits, known for his groundbreaking contributions to independent bottling and blending. Starting in the 1960s, he selected exceptional casks of Scotch whisky based on their unique character and quality, rather than age or prestige. His bottlings became highly sought after by connoisseurs, and his uncompromising standards set new benchmarks in the industry. Samaroli’s legacy includes his role as an educator and his influence on the rise of independent bottlers. Today, he is remembered as a visionary whose dedication to craftsmanship continues to inspire new generations of enthusiasts and professionals. We review a blended malt he created, but that was bottled by his widow a few years after his death, the No Age Declared Blended Malt Masam.

Three Old Cognacs From Malternative Belgium

12th March 202511th March 2025Coldorak

Malternative Belgium is a company founded by Pieter Knapen and Ysatis Thijs, dedicated to cognac. Established in 2020 as an independent bottler, Malternative Belgium combines passion and time to select and bottle cognacs. The company operates both an online business and an ‘experience store’ in Hasselt, where visitors can taste and learn about cognac in a cosy environment. The journey of Malternative Belgium began in 2009 with an interest in spirits, leading to their involvement as distributors for a reputable cognac brand in 2016. However, their vision extended beyond mere distribution; they aimed to share the rich stories and experiences that cognac offers. Through their network of small, family-owned producers in the cognac region, they source high-quality spirits (Cognacs first, but also now Calvados) under their brand. We review today three ‘old’ cognacs from Malternative Belgium, but we’ll review more recent ones in the coming weeks.

Ardbeg Eureka

10th March 202510th March 2025Coldorak

Recent Ardbeg Day releases have drawn diverse critical opinions. While some reviewers have applauded their distinctive features, others have pointed out flaws. These releases are recognised for their innovative methods, such as altering the distillation process to enhance the spirit’s texture, as demonstrated by the 2023 Ardbeg Heavy Vapours. However, some critics argue that these experiments often produce whiskies that feel underdeveloped or imbalanced, despite their intriguing ideas. Certain releases have earned praise for their unique flavour profiles, yet others have been criticised for being overpriced relative to their quality and likely age. To mark the Committee’s 25th anniversary, Ardbeg introduced a more budget-friendly NAS Committee Release, Ardbeg Eureka, whose reception remains to be seen, so let’s see how it fares.

Arran Master of Distilling

7th March 20256th March 2025Coldorak

The Master of Distilling series from Arran Distillery highlights the work of Master Distiller James MacTaggart. Each whisky in the series is made from casks personally selected by MacTaggart, showcasing the distillery’s unique style. MacTaggart’s extensive experience has significantly contributed to Arran’s reputation. The series includes two limited edition releases, with 12,000 bottles produced for each. The whiskies are aged in special casks, like Palo Cortado sherry casks, chosen by MacTaggart to enhance their flavour. The distillery, founded in 1995, is located in Lochranza, where the climate helps shape the whisky’s character. The series has received positive reviews, reflecting MacTaggart’s commitment to quality, but let’s make our own take on these Arran Master of Distilling expressions.